Resources Tax

Why do pastors owe so much at tax time, and how much should I pay each quarter?

Most pastors who are surprised by a tax bill are not doing anything wrong. They are taxed under rules that leave a large tax unpaid until April unless someone plans for it. Here is where the bill comes from, how to estimate it, and how to pay it during the year instead.

Why do pastors owe so much at tax time?

For Social Security and Medicare, a minister is treated as self-employed, so the church doesn’t withhold those taxes. The minister pays both halves, the employee’s and the employer’s, as self-employment tax (SECA) on Schedule SE. That tax applies to salary and the housing allowance, even though the housing allowance is excluded from income tax.

On top of that, income tax withholding for ministers is voluntary. Many churches withhold nothing at all.

A regular employeeA minister
Social Security and Medicare7.65%, withheld from each paycheck15.3% on 92.35% of earnings, nothing withheld
Counts the housing allowance?n/aYes
Income tax withheldYesOnly if you ask
What’s due in April if nothing changesUsually little or a refundThe full year of SECA, plus income tax

How much will I owe?

Start with self-employment tax, because it’s the large and predictable part. For a pastor with a $50,000 salary and a $20,000 housing allowance:

StepAmount
Salary plus housing allowance$70,000
× 92.35%$64,645
× 15.3% self-employment taxabout $9,900
Per quarterabout $2,475
Per monthabout $825

The 12.4% Social Security part of the 15.3% stops once earnings pass $184,500 for 2026; the 2.9% Medicare part has no cap, and an additional 0.9% Medicare tax applies at higher incomes. Half of the self-employment tax is deducted when figuring income tax, which lowers income tax a little. Then add any income tax you expect to owe, and subtract anything already withheld from your pay or your spouse’s. Our SECA estimator runs the self-employment part with your own numbers.

Unreimbursed ministry expenses reduce the self-employment tax figure, and a pastor with an approved Form 4361 owes no SECA on ministry pay. The pastor’s tax-return checklist covers both.

What are the three ways to pay during the year?

How it worksBest when
Extra withholding from the churchIf the church pays you as an employee, give it a Form W-4 asking for an extra amount per paycheck (Step 4(c)). It is withheld as income tax and credited against your total bill, self-employment tax includedYou want it automatic and the church runs payroll
Extra withholding at a spouse’s jobYour spouse raises withholding on their W-4. On a joint return it counts the same wayYour spouse has a regular paycheck
Quarterly estimates (Form 1040-ES)You pay the IRS directly four times a year, online through IRS Direct Pay or your IRS accountYou want control of the timing, or you have other self-employment income

Withholding has one advantage. The IRS treats it as paid evenly through the year, no matter when it was actually withheld. If you discover in October that you are behind, raising withholding for the rest of the year can still prevent a penalty for the earlier quarters. A late estimated payment can’t.

When are quarterly estimates due?

PaymentCovers income earnedDue
1January to MarchApril 15
2April and MayJune 15
3June to AugustSeptember 15
4September to DecemberJanuary 15 of the next year

For 2026 income those dates are April 15, June 15 and September 15, 2026, and January 15, 2027. When a date falls on a weekend or a federal holiday, it moves to the next business day. If you file your 2026 return and pay everything you owe by January 31, 2027, you don’t need to make the January 15 payment. Your state may require its own estimated payments.

How do I avoid an underpayment penalty?

You generally owe no penalty if any of these is true:

  • you owe less than $1,000 when you file, after withholding and credits;
  • withholding and on-time estimates covered at least 90% of this year’s tax;
  • they covered at least 100% of last year’s total tax, or 110% if last year’s adjusted gross income was over $150,000 ($75,000 if married filing separately). Last year’s return must have covered a full 12 months.

The last rule is the easiest to plan around, because last year’s number is already on your return. Divide it by four (after the 110% step-up if it applies), and paying that amount on time each quarter generally keeps you clear of the penalty even if this year turns out higher. You’ll still owe the difference in April, but without a penalty.

If your total tax last year was zero (or you weren’t required to file), last year covered a full 12 months, and you were a U.S. citizen or resident for the whole year, there’s no penalty this year either. That helps pastors in their first year out of seminary, though the bill itself is still due.

What changes the amount during the year?

Revisit the estimate when any of these happens:

  • a raise, or a change in the housing allowance designation;
  • a move from a parsonage to your own home, or the reverse;
  • honoraria, fees for weddings and funerals, or speaking fees (these are self-employment income too);
  • a second job;
  • a spouse starting or stopping work.

How does Angelus fit?

For the pastors we work with, we project self-employment and income tax each year and set the withholding or quarterly amounts, so the April amount is known ahead of time. See Ministers & clergy, or start a conversation.

This article is educational and not legal, tax, or investment advice. Rules are summarized from IRS Publications 517 and 505; your situation may differ.